FROM LIFE · EDITION 001 · BODY

Myth check: does Halloween candy make kids hyper?

MYTH CHECKVERIFIEDANALYSIS

What it is

The belief: sugar makes children hyperactive. The evidence: a 1995 meta-analysis in JAMA pooled 23 studies in which children had a known amount of sugar or a sweetener placebo, with children, parents and research staff all kept blind. Sugar did not affect behavior or thinking. The authors added that a small effect, or an effect in some children, couldn't be ruled out. One reason the belief may last: in a 1994 experiment, 35 mothers of boys aged 5 to 7, all described as "sugar sensitive," were told their sons had been given a large dose of sugar or a placebo. Every boy got the placebo. Mothers told their sons had had sugar rated them more hyperactive, were more controlling and kept physically closer to them, and they tended to criticize more. The question here is behavior only, not whether candy is good for anyone.

Start here

Not supported for children in general, on this evidence. The 1995 authors left the door open for a small effect or a sensitive few. Where the belief started: we couldn't pin a first source this cycle, so we don't print one.

BODY, from the Halloween calendar, reviewed by PDX-CLIN. In the loop (it gets debunked every year), kept for the 1994 experiment. General information, not medical advice; questions about a particular child belong with a pediatrician.

Sources

Also in

Myth check: does Halloween candy make kids hyper?