FROM THE LIFE CATALOG
Myth check: does Halloween candy make kids hyper?
MYTH CHECKVERIFIEDANALYSIS
What it is
The belief: sugar makes children hyperactive. A 1995 meta-analysis in JAMA pooled 23 studies in which children got a known dose of sugar or a sweetener placebo, with children, parents and researchers all kept blind. Sugar did not affect behavior or thinking, though the authors said a small effect, or an effect in some children, couldn't be ruled out. Why the belief lasts: in a 1994 experiment, 35 mothers of boys aged 5 to 7 were told their sons had been given sugar. Every boy got a placebo. Mothers who believed in the sugar rated their sons more hyperactive.
Why it survived
The 1994 experiment shows how an expectation can shape what a parent sees, which is the part most debunkings skip.
Start here
Read the 1995 JAMA meta-analysis, and the 1994 Hoover and Milich study beside it. Questions about a particular child belong with a pediatrician.
BODY, from the Halloween calendar for test edition 1, reviewed by PDX-CLIN. In the loop (it gets debunked every year), kept for the 1994 experiment.
Sources
- JAMA via PubMed: Wolraich, Wilson and White, The effect of sugar on behavior or cognition in children (1995)
- Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology: Hoover and Milich, Effects of sugar ingestion expectancies on mother-child interactions (1994)
- JAMA: Jacobson, Effects of sugar on behavior in children (letter, 1996)