FROM THE LIFE CATALOG

Myth check: are poinsettias deadly?

MYTH CHECKVERIFIED

What it is

The belief: a leaf of the Christmas plant can kill a child or a pet. The evidence: the Pittsburgh Poison Center analyzed 849,575 plant exposures reported to US poison centers. Of those, 22,793 involved poinsettias. There were no deaths. 93.3% involved children, 96.1% of patients weren't treated in a health care facility, and 92.4% had no symptoms at all. For pets, the ASPCA lists it as toxic to dogs, cats and horses because of an "irritant sap" that can upset the mouth and stomach, "but generally over-rated in toxicity."

Why it survived

The myth comes back every December, and a retrospective review of more than 22,000 poison center reports is a better answer than another rumor.

Start here

Not deadly, by this 1996 poison center review, though it can irritate. If someone or a pet eats it, call poison control or your vet, and read the study (American Journal of Emergency Medicine, 1996) for the full numbers.

BODY, from the December calendar, checked against the 1996 study (American Journal of Emergency Medicine) and the ASPCA's plant list. In the loop (it's retold every year), kept for the numbers. General information, not medical or veterinary advice.

Sources