FROM THE LIFE CATALOG
The year the White House served applesauce
VERIFIEDCLAIMANALYSISTASTE
What it is
On 9 November 1959, seventeen days before Thanksgiving, Health, Education and Welfare Secretary Arthur Flemming said cranberries from Oregon and Washington had been found with traces of aminotriazole, a weed killer some lab tests had linked to thyroid cancer in rats. Stores pulled cranberry products within hours, WBUR reported in 2019, and the White House served applesauce. Flemming was applying the Delaney Clause, added to food law a year earlier, which barred any additive found to cause cancer in people or animals, at any dose. Between $45 million and $50 million of the crop went unsold. In the early 1960s, Ocean Spray pushed to sell cranberries all year with Cranberry Juice Cocktail.
Why it survived
A food scare, a law with no threshold and a juice in your fridge, all in one story about trusting what you can't test.
Start here
WBUR's 2019 piece, "How a nationwide cancer scare nearly sank the cranberry industry," then Janzen's dissertation if you want the law.
Read WBUR first, then Janzen. WBUR has the people who were there; Janzen has the paper trail.
FOOD, for test edition 3's Detour, from the Thanksgiving calendar, then WBUR, Yankee (1980), Janzen's history, the National Academies and the EPA. In the loop.
Sources
- WBUR: How a nationwide cancer scare nearly sank the cranberry industry (2019)
- Yankee: The Thanksgiving without cranberry sauce (November 1980)
- Texas A&M: Janzen, The Cranberry Scare of 1959 (2011), record and abstract
- National Academies: The Delaney Clause and other regulatory actions (1982)
- EPA: Summary of the Food Quality Protection Act