FROM THE LIFE CATALOG
Three pianists, one unfinished piece, no instructions
VERIFIEDANALYSIS
What it is
Around 1878 to 1880, the English composer Ethel Smyth wrote a short piano piece called "Aus der Jugendzeit!! E. v. H.", for her friend Elisabeth von Herzogenberg. The manuscript gives no tempo, no dynamics, no expression marks, and the piece doesn't finish. Christopher Wiley of the University of Surrey measured the three professional recordings, by Liana Gavrila-Șerbescu (1995), Heloise Ph. Palmer (2017) and Carolyn Enger (2020), beat by beat. They barely agree, least of all at the ending. Most classical music reaches a pianist with a tradition attached. This piece arrived with notes and nothing else.
Why it survived
It turns a dry measuring study into something you can test with your own ears in ten minutes, and nobody can tell you your favorite ending is wrong.
Start here
Play the three recordings back to back and listen only to the last ten seconds of each. Wiley's fix for a lost tradition is to read the composer's memoirs, where Smyth describes the friend the music portrays.
Connection
Atoui's Turbine Hall piece faces the same problem from the other end: neither has a fixed version (Tate; Wiley).
SOUND, far shelf, for test edition 1: a University of Surrey release, then the paper's record in Performance Research (vol. 29, no. 6). Outside the loop.